Skip to main content

Table 6 Key differences among the three cadres of health workers

From: For more than love or money: attitudes of student and in-service health workers towards rural service in India

Students

Allopathic cadre

Ayurvedic cadre

Nursing cadre

Attitude toward rural primary care

 →  Preferred jobs were in the urban private sector

 →  Open to both private and public job options, though preference was for the public sector

 →  Generally preferred jobs in the public sector. A few nurses had ambitions to work abroad

 →  Rural primary care jobs are perceived as not providing professional growth and respect

 →  Jobs in the primary health center give legitimacy to alternate health professions

 →  Rural primary care jobs in the public sector offered job security and satisfying work hours

 →  Specialization/postgraduate opportunities given utmost importance

Key concerns of students in taking up rural primary care jobs

 →  Lack of professional growth

 →  Poor salary

 →  Job security wanted

 →  Inability to practice alternate medicine

 →  Adequate workload

 →  Poor salary

 →  Lack of work related facilities

 →  And regular timings wanted

 →  Several contextual factors

 →  Lack of job prestige

 →  Inability to take leave during emergencies

 →  Poor personal security

 →  Lack of work-related facilities

 →  Several contextual factors

 →  Several contextual factors

Concerns of in-service personnel in rural primary care jobs

 →  Fear of prolonged stints with no guarantee of transfers from rural area

 →  Fear of prolonged stints with no guarantee of transfers from rural area

 →  Fear of prolonged stints with no guarantee of transfers from rural area

 →  Poor status and salary in comparison with allopathic doctors

 →  Inability to take leave

 →  Inability to assist patients during the

 →  Poor salary compared to private practitioners

 →  Several contextual factors

 →  Lack of Ayurvedic drugs

 →  Several contextual factors

 →  Bureaucracy in public sectors jobs

 →  Several contextual factors