Skip to main content

Table 3 Articles related to natural disasters

From: Health workforce strategies in response to major health events: a rapid scoping review with lessons learned for the response to the COVID-19 pandemic

Natural disasters

First author (year)

Emergency

(year)

Types of challenges

Types of strategies

Provider groups

Setting

Type of article

Types of evaluations

Amat Camacho (2019)

[40]

Nepal earthquake (2015)

Damaged/reduced/insufficient facilities, mass casualty/patient surge

Increase numbers: solidarity staffing (e.g., deployments to/from other jurisdictions)

Physicians, nurses, military health workers

Critical care, emergency medical services, hospitals, public health

Literature review and case study

Data about patients/procedures, data about workforce

Burnweit (2011)

[41]

Haiti earthquake (2010)

Damaged/reduced/insufficient facilities, mass casualty/patient surge, unmet health and social needs

Increase numbers: solidarity staffing (e.g., deployments to/from other jurisdictions), International Emergency Medical Relief, Field hospital

Increase support: housing for front-line workers

Physicians, nurses, pharmacists, social workers, medical imaging workers

Critical care, diagnostic services, emergency medical services, hospitals

Observational–descriptive

Data about patients/procedures, Data about workforce; Challenges (pitfalls)

Catlett (2011)

[42]

Haiti earthquake (2010)

Damaged/reduced/insufficient facilities, mass casualty/patient surge, unmet health and social needs

Increase numbers: solidarity staffing (e.g., deployments to/from other jurisdictions), Naval hospital ship

Increase support: mental health support

Physicians, nurses

Critical care, emergency medical services, hospitals, primary health care

Observational–descriptive

Challenges (barriers)/enablers (facilitators)

Chaudhary (2017)

[43]

Nepal earthquake (2015)

damaged/reduced/insufficient facilities

Increase numbers: solidarity staffing (e.g., deployments to/from other jurisdictions), cross-sector staff deployments

Increase flexibility: cross-sector deployments

Physicians, nurses, midwives

Community health services, hospitals, other

Systematic review

Data about patients/procedures; data about workforce; lessons learned

Fredricks (2017)

[44]

Nepal earthquake (2015)

Unmet health and social needs

Increase flexibility: new roles, expanded roles

Community health workers

Community health services

Analytical–qualitative

Experiences of workers

Kondo (2019)

[45]

Japan earthquake (2016)

Damaged/reduced/insufficient facilities, mass casualty/patient surge, unmet health and social needs

Increase numbers: solidarity staffing (e.g., deployments to/from other jurisdictions), cross-sector staff deployments, Emergency Medical Relief

Physicians, nurses

Critical care, emergency medical services, hospitals, public health

Observational–descriptive

Data about workforce, data about patients/procedures, lessons learned

Lane (2006)

[46]

Indian Ocean earthquake/tsunamis (2004)

Damaged/reduced/insufficient facilities, mass casualty/patient surge, unmet health and social needs

Increase numbers: solidarity staffing (e.g., deployments to/from other jurisdictions)

Increase flexibility: expanded roles

Physicians, nurses, military health workers, dental workers

Community health services, emergency medical services, other

Observational–descriptive

Data about workforce, lessons learned

Manning (2006)

[47]

Indian Ocean earthquake/tsunamis (2004)

Unmet health and social needs

Increase numbers: solidarity staffing (e.g., deployments to/from other jurisdictions) Increase support: mental health services

Community health workers, mental health workers, social workers

Community health services, mental health services, other

Observational–descriptive

Challenges, lessons learned

Roshchin (2002)

[48]

India earthquake (2001)

Damaged/reduced/insufficient facilities, mass casualty/patient surge, unmet health and social needs, reduced workforce

Increase numbers: solidarity staffing (e.g., deployments to/from other jurisdictions), international humanitarian emergency response/relief

Physicians, nurses, paramedics

Critical care, emergency medical services, hospitals, primary health care, public health

Observational–descriptive

Data about patients/procedures, challenges (problems), lessons learned

Waxman (2006)

[49]

Indian Ocean earthquake/tsunamis (2004)

Damaged/reduced/insufficient facilities, mass casualty/patient surge, unmet health and social needs

Increase numbers: solidarity staffing (e.g., deployments to/from other jurisdictions)

Physicians, nurses, military health workers, public health workers

Emergency medical services, hospitals

Observational–descriptive

Data about patients/procedures, data about workforce, lessons learned