Variables | Physician | Nurses | Health promoters | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Available supply (As) | Ideal supply (Is) | Available supply (As) | Ideal supply (Is) | Available supply (As) | Ideal supply (Is) | ||||
Annual hours available 2009 | Annual hours estimated time used | Annual hours estimated time required | Annual hours available 2009 | Annual hours estimated timeused | Annual hours estimated time required | Annual hours available 2009 | Annual hours estimated time used | Annual hours estimated time required | |
(a) | (a1) | (a2) | (b) | (b1) | (b2) | (c) | (cl) | (c2) | |
Urban PHFs (n = 12) | |||||||||
Total hours | 141 600 | 373 462.6 | 562 069.7 | 220 800 | 231 150.6 | 332 150.6 | 27 600 | 243 449.9 | 406 915.0 |
Median (h) | 12 000 | 22 624.2 | 35 876.9 | 17 400 | 12 654.8 | 21 913.9 | 0 | 16 749.0 | 32 658.9 |
As − Is | −10 624.2 | −23 876.9 | 4 475.3 | 4 513.9 | −16 749.0 | −32 658.9 | |||
Wilcoxon (P value) | 0.0029 | 0.002 2 | 0.209 4* | 0.099 5* | 0.002 2 | 0.002 2 | |||
Friedman (P value) | 0.001 3 | 0.001 2 | 0.028 0 | ||||||
Rural PHFs (n = 8) | |||||||||
Total hours | 30 000 | 628 853.6 | 84 632.2 | 38 400 | 40 127.2 | 57 173.1 | 1 200 | 35 627.8 | 52 308.2 |
Median | 1 800 | 4 079.7 | 5 460.1 | 1 200 | 2 173.6 | 3 182.4 | 0 | 2 151.3 | 3 714.2 |
As − Is | −2 279.7 | −3 660.1 | −973.6 | −1 982.4 | −2 151.3 | −3 714.2 | |||
Wilcoxon (P value) | 0.049 9 | 0.017 3 | NA | NA | NA | NA | |||
Friedman (P value) | 0.026 2 | 0.083 7* | 0.170 5* | ||||||
Total PHFs (n = 20) | |||||||||
Total hours | 171 600 | 436 316.2 | 646 701.9 | 259 200 | 271 545.6 | 389 393.7 | 28 800 | 279 077.7 | 459 223.2 |
Median | 6 000 | 12 478.5 | 16 510.6 | 10 800 | 7 904.6 | 11 321.3 | 0 | 7 220.7 | 9 252 |
As − Is | −6 478.5 | −10 510.6 | 2 895.4 | −521.3 | −7 220.7 | −9 252 | |||
Wilcoxon (P value) | 0.000 4 | 0.000 1 | 0.262 7* | 0.018 7 | 0.000 1 | 0.000 1 | |||
Friedman (P value) | 0.000 | 0.000 1 | 0.016 7 |