Skip to main content

Table 1 Inclusion and exclusion criteria

From: Interventions for health workforce retention in rural and remote areas: a systematic review

 

Include

Exclude

Year published

2010 or later

Prior to 2010

Participant types

Medical doctors, nurses, midwives, pharmacists, allied health professions, or health professionals generally

Other types of workers in the health sector or in other sectors

Countries

High-income country as per World Bank criteria [23], or if mixed income countries then data for high-income countries reported separately

Not high income or not reported separately

Exposure

Interventions, support measures or incentive programs implemented (or simulated) with the intention of increasing retention or reducing turnover

No intervention (or simulation) designed to impact on retention or turnover

Setting

Rural or remote as defined by ASGS (Australia) or equivalent national classification system or study's own description of being rural or remote

Not rural or remote

Outcomes

PRIMARY: Mean or median length of employment; survival probabilities; hazard, odds or relative risk ratios for staying/leaving rural; stability rates; settlement rates. (profile = retention in rural/remote area or community) SECONDARY: Vacancy rates; unfilled positions; turnover numbers or rates; attrition or wastage rates; rate of leaving before end of contract; intention to stay/leave; intention to return

Lack of quantifiable primary or secondary outcomes, job satisfaction

Study types

Analytical observational studies (prospective and retrospective cohort studies, case–control studies, cross-sectional studies); descriptive observational studies (case series, descriptive cross-sectional studies)

Qualitative studies

Language

English

Non-English